Rene Descartes 1596-1650 Descartes took it for granted that "mind" or "soul" existed in different universes. He wondered about how these universes communicated. Specifically, he wondered how "spirit" can move "matter". There are many who still take the idea of the spirit world seriously. They imagine the "soul" can be separated from the body and migrates on to some other universe (heaven) at death or somehow migrate to another body. Let's put this belief system to one side. From here on, I will speak to those who don't take this idea seriously. These days, those of us who are scientifically inclined imagine the "mind" to be a phenomenon that somehow happens in the Universe that is governed by physical law (and perhaps other laws so far undiscovered). Exactly how this happens is a live debate and a key area of investigation in the new university departments of "Cognitive Studies". These same departmen...

Descartes is the poster-boy for the method of " reductionism ", which I think of as "Math Envy". This is the idea that you can build up all knowledge from simple principles. These days, we pretend to start with Quantum  Mechanics, yet we are awarding Nobel Prizes for people who make "baby steps" from Quantum Mechanics to the chemistry of Hydrogen. The fact is that reductionism is dead. There is no path from "simple" to "complex". We need to start somewhere else. That's good news, since it turns out that we all know a Hell of a lot more than we thought we did. It turns out that we can start with what we all share and what we know: the fantastic and virtually limitless capabilities of the human mind. We don't need to "boil it down" to something simpler, or "explain" it in terms of chattering neurons. We learn very little about our minds by comparing them to the "minds" of chimpanzees, cats and frogs. ...